Carnell Tate Camp Update — August 16: Zero for Three Under the Lights, Perfect in the Red Zone
2026 NFL Season · Monday, Aug 17
Tate went zero for three on targets from Cam Ward in the preseason opener, then caught two of Ward's red-zone touchdowns in Saturday's practice. The fourth overall pick's rookie evidence is arriving exactly as scrambled as August evidence usually is.
Follow Carnell Tate and get every episode, every week.
The full episode, in writing
Carnell Tate was targeted three times by Cam Ward in Thursday's preseason opener at the 49ers and caught none of them, per Easton Freeze's charting at A to Z Sports. 48 hours later he caught two red-zone touchdowns from the same quarterback in the best practice of Ward's camp, per Jim Wyatt at TennesseeTitans.com. Welcome to evaluating rookies in August.
Our June preview of Tate was mostly a refusal, and we stand by the refusal. Tennessee took him fourth overall, the first receiver drafted, and general manager Mike Borgonzi called him the best receiver in the class. But we tested whether draft capital plus camp buzz predicts rookie production, and it does not at a standard we would cite, so we declined to convert his draft slot into a stat line. What we said instead was watch two things: whether he breaks camp as an every-down outside starter, and where the targets actually flow once September arrives.
The first question is answering yes. Tate is running with the first offense, drawing starter targets in the game and starter reps all week. In Tuesday's joint practice he caught three passes including an acrobatic sideline grab, per Wyatt, and he was central enough to the proceedings that a hard hit on him from 49ers corner Renardo Green touched off the first of the day's three brawls, with Ward sprinting in to defend him. "I'm always going to have the back of my teammates," Ward said afterward, "because that's the brotherhood that we have in our locker room." A franchise quarterback throwing hands for his rookie tells you something about the rookie's standing, if nothing about his route tree.
The second question is genuinely mixed. The Ward-to-Tate connection is live and productive in practice, three catches Saturday including the two scores, and zero for three when the lights came on. Ward himself pointed at it postgame, saying the pass game needs cleaning up "with the receivers seeing eye-to-eye."
Does the June read hold? UNCHANGED — we made no production claim to confirm or break, and this week's split evidence is exactly why. The role is trending toward every-down starter, which was checkable item one; the live chemistry is not there yet, which keeps item two open. Next week: the Seahawks joint practice and game, and specifically whether Ward and Tate connect in game action for the first time. We'll check next Sunday.
_Data via nflverse._
Keep going