Garrett Wilson

Garrett Wilson is a three-time thousand-yard alpha who just lost most of a season to a knee — and whose biggest problem isn't the knee, it's that nobody knows who's throwing him the ball in 2026. The Muffed 2026 preview.

The 2025 season was seven games of elite usage cut short: a thirty-five percent target share and a fifty-six percent air-yards share before a knee sprain ended it — among the highest alpha workloads in football. The signature was a Week 4 deep touchdown from Justin Fields at Miami. When healthy, he's the entire passing game.

The arc is the reassuring part: ninety-five catches, a hundred one catches, then the injury-shortened year. Wilson has been a remarkably stable high-volume alpha since he entered the league — three straight seasons around a thousand yards on bad offenses with worse quarterbacks. The volume is bankable. The scoring never has been, because the quarterback play never has been.

What repeats: the targets, emphatically — a thirty-five-percent share is the stickiest, safest usage in the sport, and his has been elite for years. What caps him is everything downstream of the throw. His touchdown share spiked to twenty-four percent in a seven-game sample, which is noise, not signal.

The situation has resolved more than it's still unsettled, per the reports: the Jets traded Justin Fields to Kansas City and brought in Geno Smith as the new starter, with new offensive coordinator Frank Reich planning to move Wilson around the formation — X, F, and Z — and target him heavily. That's a real answer to last year's biggest question mark, even if "answer" doesn't mean "upgrade" is guaranteed. Wilson himself is past the knee injury that ended his 2025 early — full health, by his own account ("I feel great") and the staff's ("he looks really good"). A proven alpha is only as good as the arm feeding him, and that arm is now a known, established veteran rather than a question mark.

The price: pick forty-two, the nineteenth receiver. Verdict: WATCHLIST — the volume profile is genuinely WR1-caliber and the price is a discount, but a new play-caller and a new-to-him veteran quarterback are still two variables we haven't seen on the field together. The counter for him: if Reich and Smith produce even competent quarterback play, a thirty-four-percent-share alpha in the games he played at WR19 is a steal. Against: it's still an unproven pairing, and his ceiling has always been quarterback-gated.

September watch: the Reich-Smith offense in live games, full stop; then whether the target share returns to its elite level now that health isn't the question. If he's one of your guys, Muffed builds this show for your whole roster — every player, every week, all season.