Indianapolis Colts success rate, 2026
43.0%
19th of 32 in the NFL
- 43.5%
- On 251 offensive plays through Week 5
How often do the Colts stay on schedule?
The Colts offense has a success rate of 43.0% through Week 5 — the share of its plays that added expected points — 19th in the NFL.
Week by week
| Through | Off Succ% | Rank |
|---|---|---|
| Week 1 | 41.5% | 22nd |
| Week 2 | 44.8% | 12th |
| Week 3 | 43.3% | 16th |
| Week 4 | 43.0% | 19th |
| Week 5 | 43.0% | 19th |
Last season
Down from 46.3% in 2025, which ranked 8th of 32.
From the Colts weekly
Third and two at the Washington five, three twenty-nine left in the first half, Colts down six to nothing, with an extra lineman reported as eligible. Jonathan Taylor went around left end for the touchdown, and Spencer Shrader's extra point put Indianapolis ahead seven to six. It never trailed again. The Colts beat the Commanders thirty to thirteen, their second straight win, and they are two and two.
Read the Week 4 note →Which offenses have the best success rate in 2026?
San Francisco 49ers (54.5%), Baltimore Ravens (51.7%), then Jacksonville Jaguars (49.5%) lead the league. All 32 teams on the Team Success Rate and Explosive Play Rate board.
Use Muffed in your AI
Ask Claude or ChatGPT football questions and get these verified figures back, with sources. Add https://muffed.ai/api/mcp — free, no account, no API key.