Jonathan Taylor or James Cook III?
Jonathan Taylor or James Cook III? Both are RBs. Here is what each man's 2025 season was actually built on, updated Aug 1, 2026. Jonathan Taylor leads on share of his team's offensive snaps and rushing attempts, and also on receiving expected points added — one side of that is opportunity, the other is efficiency, and they have not historically travelled together. James Cook III's edge sits in rushing yards over expected and rushing yards over expected per attempt — efficiency rather than opportunity, and the file measures that as the less repeatable half. Figures are 2025 verified play-by-play (nflverse); scored Half-PPR. Repeatability is measured from year-over-year persistence across 2016 to 2025, not projected. Muffed publishes no projections, draft grades or start/sit advice.
Jonathan Taylor
RB · Indianapolis Colts
James Cook III
RB · Buffalo Bills
Jonathan Taylor vs James Cook III, 2025
| Metric | Jonathan Taylor | James Cook III |
|---|---|---|
| 2025 finish | 2 | 6 |
| Half-PPR/G | 20.0 | 16.8 |
| Games | 17 | 17 |
| Snap share | 82.8%37th | 58.1%108th |
| Availability | 81.2%149th | 98.5%4th |
| RYOE | 195.15th of 49 | 358.21st of 49 |
| RYOE/att | 0.6118th of 49 | 1.172nd of 49 |
| Carries | 323 | 309 |
| Rec EPA | 9.29th | 8.712th |
A dash means the panel holds no qualifying figure for that player — usually too few games or attempts to clear the metric's floor, not a zero. Ranks are the source's own, against the population shown.
What repeats
Jonathan Taylor leads on share of his team's offensive snaps and rushing attempts, and also on receiving expected points added — one side of that is opportunity, the other is efficiency, and they have not historically travelled together. James Cook III's edge sits in rushing yards over expected and rushing yards over expected per attempt — efficiency rather than opportunity, and the file measures that as the less repeatable half. Of the two, Jonathan Taylor's season rests on the steadier ground. That is a statement about what each man's production was built on, not a running order — and it is a description of 2025, not a forecast of 2026.
“Repeats” is measured year-over-year persistence across 2016 to 2025 — opportunity carries between seasons, scoring rate largely does not. This describes what a 2025 season was built on. It is not a forecast, and Muffed publishes no projections, draft grades or start/sit advice. How we measure it.
Settle it — hear both stories
The same verified data, told as the story of each man's season.
Related
Get the story behind the numbers
The same AI that built these tables reads every play of every game and tells you what actually happened — as pages you can read and shows you can listen to, from this same verified data.
Get the weekly. The verified read on the NFL, every Tuesday of the season — and if you build a show, yours arrives with it.
Free. First edition lands Week 1 — Sept 9.
In a Sleeper league? One link gets every team its own show — free, no signup.
Set up your league →Cite this
Muffed, “Jonathan Taylor vs James Cook III, 2025 verified comparison,” muffed.ai/compare/jonathan-taylor-vs-james-cook. Through the 2025 season. Data via nflverse · NFL Next Gen Stats via nflverse; FTN Data via nflverse.
Free to quote and link with credit. The underlying figures are recomputed from public play-by-play — see how we verify every number.