Lions, Week 1 — What Repeats: More Play-Action, Less Payoff

Detroit ran play-action on 14 of 41 dropbacks against New Orleans on Sunday — 34 percent, seventh-highest of the 32 offenses in Week 1, against a league median of 21 and against 25 and a half percent across all of last season. Jared Goff's 14 play-action throws produced seven completions and 48 yards. His other 25 throws produced 19 completions and a hundred 58. Across 2025 the fake paid: a hundred 47 play-action throws, a hundred two completions, 1388 yards. Put Sunday's 14 next to that and the shape is the same fake, called more often, going a lot shorter. The Recap counted one completion of 20 or more yards all afternoon; the play-action throws contributed 48 yards on 14.

The rest of Goff's charting was cleaner than the yardage. 39 charted throws, 31 of them catchable — 79 and a half percent, sixth-highest in the league this week and six points above his own 73 percent across last season. One interception-worthy ball, a throw a defender should have caught: 2.6 percent, tied for 20-second in the league, which is the good end, though up from 1.6 last season. No interceptions, one throwaway, no sack charted as his fault, and one dropback outside the pocket in 40, against 60 in 614 across 2025. The number that did move is contested throws — a receiver and a defender arriving together — six of 39, 15 percent, double his seven percent from last season. So he was more accurate than usual and threw into more traffic than usual, and his receivers dropped two of the 31 catchable balls.

The run game saw heavier boxes than it is used to. 32 designed runs with a charted box count, a hundred 63 yards. New Orleans showed six or fewer in the box on 15 of the 32 — 47 percent, sixteenth in the league this week and right at the median — against 61 percent across all of last season, and the average box was 6.6 defenders against 6.4. Two other things fell away: screens, two of 41 dropbacks, five percent against 10 last year, and run-pass options, none at all against four percent. Motion barely moved — 44 of 97 charted plays, 45 percent, sixteenth in the league, against 47 across last season.

The defense sent more than it did last year. Five or more rushers on 22 of 63 Saints dropbacks — 35 percent, tenth-highest of any defense this week, against 27 percent across last season. A charted extra rusher on 27 of the 63, 43 percent, against 32. 4.6 rushers per dropback, against 4.3. New Orleans went no-huddle on 22 percent of its snaps, double the 11 percent this defense saw last season, and put a man in motion on half its charted plays. Against the run, Detroit showed a light box on nine of 23 Saints designed runs, 39 percent — last season it showed one on 24 percent, so the box was lighter than this defense's 2025 habit — and allowed 87 yards on the 23.

Tyler Shough's throws against it, 57 charted: 41 catchable, 72 percent, where this defense allowed 69 last season. 12 contested, 21 percent — one throw in five against this defense was contested, where opponents were contested on 17 percent of throws last year, and Shough himself on 10 percent across his 2025. Two interception-worthy balls. The Recap counted three takeaways in all. Three catches charted as created by the receiver. Two drops on the 41 catchable. The charting cannot split the half the Recap split. What it can say is that Detroit sent five or more on more than a third of dropbacks, one throw in five against it was contested, it took the ball away three times, and it allowed 410 passing yards.

The stat lines have settled, so here they are, scored half-PPR. Jahmyr Gibbs led the team with 31.1 — 29 carries for a hundred 56 and both touchdowns, +5 catches on five targets for 30. Amon-Ra St. Brown, 10 catches on 14 targets for 67 two touchdowns, 23.7. Goff, 26 of 39 for 206, two touchdowns, no interceptions, 16.4. Sam LaPorta, five catches on eight targets for 48, 7.3. Jameson Williams, four catches on nine targets for 45, 6.5. For New Orleans, Chris Olave caught 10 of 13 targets for a hundred 82, 23.2, and Shough threw for 410 yards on 35 completions, three touchdowns and two interceptions, also 23.2. Devaughn Vele, seven catches on nine targets for 69 and a touchdown, 16.4.

One thing has to be said clearly enough that nobody mistakes what this episode is doing. The show's name asks what repeats, and there has only been one game, so nothing has had the chance to. Through Week 3, every "against last season" in this episode is exactly that — Sunday set beside the 2025 Lions, a roster that has changed in places, a year older everywhere, some players in different jobs. That comparison finds what was unusual about Sunday, and that is worth something. It does not find what is true about this team. The within-season version, Detroit against its own recent weeks, begins working around Week 4, and until it does we will say which comparison is on the table every time.

The thread starts here, so here is the whole of it. Last season, as the Recap laid out, this offense finished fourth in the league in expected points per pass play — expected points being what a snap was worth given down, distance and field position — and third in explosive-play rate, and the defense tied for fourth in the league with 49 sacks. Three things go in the notebook. Play-action was called at the seventh-highest rate in the league and produced 48 yards on 14 throws, from an offense that took 1388 yards off that fake last season. Goff's catchable rate was sixth in the league and his contested rate doubled, and neither cost him a turnover. And the defense sent five or more rushers more often than its 2025 average, one throw in five against it was contested, and it allowed 410 passing yards. None of them is a trend after one game, and a game with a first half and a second half that different is the last one to draw a line through.

That's your Lions — every game, by the numbers. This is Muffed: we do the same deep dive for all 32 teams. Follow the Lions show wherever you're listening, so next week's recap lands the moment it's out. No theater. Just the football.

And if you play fantasy, there's a Muffed show built around your exact roster — free at muffed.ai.

_Data via nflverse. Charting: FTN Data via nflverse._