Saints 17, Panthers 20 — Week 10: Three Trips, No Points by Half

2026 NFL Season · Monday, Nov 16

New Orleans lost 20-17 at home to Carolina on a 54-yard field goal with 2 seconds left, after three first-half possessions reached the Panthers' 40, 35 and 25 and ended in an interception, a fumble and a fourth-and-1 stop.

The full read

New Orleans lost 20-17 at home to Carolina on Sunday and fell to 3-6. Charlie Smyth tied it from 55 yards with 45 seconds left; 43 seconds later Ryan Fitzgerald won it for the Panthers from 54. The first half cost the most. Three possessions reached the Carolina 40, 35 and 25 and ended in an interception, a fumble and a fourth-and-1 stop, and the Saints trailed 7-0 at the break. 11 drives produced two touchdowns, a field goal, two turnovers, a turnover on downs and two three-and-outs.

The passing game moved the ball more often than its total says, and success rate, the share of plays that gained what the situation asked for, shows it: 44.7% of 38 pass plays succeeded. Expected points added (EPA), what a play is worth given down, distance and field position against what the situation was already worth, had it at -5.0, -0.13 a play against -0.01 through Week 9, and one throw carried all of that: the fourth-and-1 interception on the opening drive, -6.4. The other 37 were worth +1.5. Tyler Shough completed 25 of 35 for 187 yards, a touchdown and an interception, and was sacked three times. Jordyn Tyson was the target on 13 throws and caught 11 for 80. Chris Olave caught 3 of 4 for 30, his fewest targets this season.

The run game was Muffed, and total EPA sizes it: 23 rush plays worth -15.4, -0.67 a play against -0.08 through Week 9, and only 17.4% succeeded. Travis Etienne, in his first game since Week 3, ran 8 times for 14 yards, Audric Estime 7 times for 6, and Alvin Kamara twice for 4 and a 3-yard touchdown. The six runs with 2 yards or fewer to go gained 2 yards in all. Shough's fumble did the most damage: first and 10 at the Carolina 35 in the second quarter, he lost 5 yards and Jaelan Phillips recovered, -6.1 EPA, and the Panthers drove for the game's first touchdown.

The pass defense was the best unit New Orleans had, and EPA per play allowed tells it: Carolina's 33 pass plays were worth -0.21 apiece, against +0.09 allowed through Week 9. On defense a negative number is good. Bryce Young completed 17 of 30 for 200 yards and no touchdowns, and the defense owned the late downs: Carolina's 12 third- and fourth-down pass plays were worth -13.0, 2 succeeded, and all three sacks came there. The first set the tone. After the interception, fourth and 2 at the New Orleans 3, Carl Granderson sacked Young for no gain, -3.5 EPA for Carolina and 12.2 points of win probability, the estimate of each side's chance to win. Colby Wooden and Kaden Elliss had the other two, both on third down in the third quarter. The leak was the backs: Chuba Hubbard caught 5 of 5 for 80.

The run defense played the Panthers to their average, and EPA per play allowed shows it: 32 rush plays worth +0.009 apiece against +0.010 allowed through Week 9. Hubbard carried 27 times for 92 yards and 2 touchdowns, but only 28.1% of Carolina's runs succeeded, and the 16 after halftime were worth -2.5. The goal-line stand nearly held. Up 14-10 with 2:00 left, Carolina first and goal at the 1, Khristian Boyd and Chase Young dropped Hubbard for a 1-yard loss and Elliss held him to 1 yard on second down. He scored on third and 1 with 1:51 left.

The game turned in its last 41 seconds. Smyth's 55-yarder, set up by a 5-yard Tyson catch and a 15-yard face-mask flag on Tyrel Dodson, tied it 17-17 and was worth 19.4 points of win probability. Then, second and 10 at the Carolina 34 with 28 seconds left, Kool-Aid McKinstry was flagged for pass interference on a throw for Jalen Coker: 30 yards to the New Orleans 36, 19.5 points. Hubbard ran for no gain, and Fitzgerald's 54-yarder with 2 seconds left was worth 29.0 points, the largest swing of the game.

Last week's episode asked whether a quarterback sacked five times by the Browns could get the passing game back above its season rate. The sacks came down to three, and the passing game did not get back: -0.13 a play against -0.01 through Week 9, though it was +0.08 a play across 22 second-half pass plays. The one to watch next: whether a run game that gained 24 yards on 17 running-back carries and 2 yards on six short-yardage runs can convert a third or fourth and 1.

That's your Saints, every game, by the numbers. Muffed does the same deep dive for all 32 teams. Follow the Saints on Muffed and next week's episode is waiting the moment it's out. No theater. Just the football.

_Data via nflverse._

Every Saints episode

Season reviews, draft recaps and every game recap, in one place.

More like this