The Muffed Take
ADP #241Muffed: WATCHLIST

the WR96 per-game line screams value and the point-four-six-one touchdown rate screams regression, and both are true, which is exactly why it's a watch and not a buy. The shin heals clean and Horton earns real targets behind Smith-Njigba and the talent that flashed is worth a pick-232 dart; the leg lingers or the five scores normalize with no volume bump and the eighty-sixth-in-total half-season is the honest picture.

2026 PreviewJul 4, 2026

Tory Horton 2026 Season Preview — what repeats, what doesn't

0:000:00

Your episode · 0:00

Show notes & transcript

Tory Horton scored five touchdowns on thirteen catches last season before a shin injury ended his rookie year in November — and that touchdown rate is the most unrepeatable line in this entire range. Receiver ninety-six, pick two-thirty-two: a price that looks like a value on the per-game number and a trap once you see what built it. This is about a promising rookie, a fluky scoring rate, and a leg that needs to heal.

The season: eight games before the injury, thirteen catches on twenty-two targets for a hundred sixty-one yards and five scores. On Half-PPR scoring that is seven-point-three points a game — fiftieth among receivers per game, but only eighty-sixth in total, because he played half a year. And here is the number that matters: a touchdown share of point-four-six, five scores on a hundred sixty-one receiving yards. Receivers do not score once every two and a half catches. That is not a skill you project forward; it is variance that arrived in a cluster.

The career arc is a partial rookie year, so we read it carefully: a fifth-round pick who flashed real ability and a nose for the end zone in a small sample, then got hurt. Ten-point-six percent of Seattle's targets in his games — a rotational rookie share — turned into a lot of points because almost all of it found paydirt.

The pattern beat is the whole caution. Our what-sticks research is blunt about touchdowns: they are the weather, the least repeatable thing a receiver does. A five-score rookie half-season on a hundred sixty-one yards is weather at its most extreme; normalize the rate and the underlying line is a thirteen-catch, one-hundred-sixty-yard rotational rookie. The targets are the identity stat, and his targets were modest. The production was loud; the usage was quiet.

The situation is a healing leg and a crowded, excellent room. Horton's rookie year ended on a shin injury that required offseason surgery, per the beat, and he missed all of spring — the coaching staff's word in June was that he should be back around the start of training camp, encouraging but not settled. The room he returns to is stacked: Jaxon Smith-Njigba is a bona fide number one coming off a monster season, and Cooper Kupp is in Seattle now too. Klint Kubiak left to run Las Vegas, so Brian Fleury calls the plays, with Sam Darnold at quarterback for the defending champions. Horton is a talented third or fourth receiver on a very good passing team — real upside if the leg is right and a target or two opens, real traffic if it does not.

The price: receiver ninety-six at pick two-thirty-two. The slot pays three-point-six a game; he produced seven-point-three, almost all of it on touchdowns that will not repeat at that rate. Our verdict: watchlist. The per-game line screams value and the touchdown rate screams regression, and both are true — which is exactly why this is a watch, not a buy. The caveat both ways: if the shin heals clean and Horton earns real targets behind Smith-Njigba, the talent that flashed is worth a two-thirty-two dart — and if the leg lingers or the scores normalize with no volume bump, the eighty-sixth-in-total half-season is the honest picture.

Watch the shin's camp timeline first — no health, no episode — then his target share against that ten-point-six percent, then whether the touchdowns come with yards attached this time. The talent is real; the touchdown rate was a mirage. If he's one of your guys, this show exists for your whole roster — every player, every week, all season.

Play fantasy? There's a version of this about your whole roster — build your show, free →

2025 by the numbers
Finish
WR96
PPR / game
8.1
Total PPR
65.1
Games
8
2026 ADP
#241

Want Tory Horton on your weekly show?

Build a free show around Tory Horton (and your other guys) right now — no signup. Want it in your inbox every week of the 2026 season? Drop your email once you've built it.