Panthers 20, Saints 17 — Week 10: A 54-Yarder With 2 Seconds Left

2026 NFL Season · Monday, Nov 16

Carolina won 20-17 at New Orleans on Ryan Fitzgerald's 54-yard field goal with 2 seconds left, after Chuba Hubbard scored both touchdowns and a run defense that forced a fumble held the Saints to 49 yards on 23 rush plays.

The full read

Carolina won 20-17 at New Orleans on Sunday, ended a three-game losing streak and moved to 4-5. Ryan Fitzgerald won it from 54 yards with 2 seconds left, 43 seconds after the Saints had tied it 17-17 on a 55-yarder. 11 drives produced two touchdowns, two field goals, a turnover on downs and no giveaways.

The passing game won early downs and gave it back late, and expected points added (EPA), what a play is worth given down, distance and field position against what the situation was already worth, splits it cleanly: 21 pass plays on first and second down worth +6.0, 12 on third and fourth down worth -13.0, and only 2 of those 12 succeeded. For the game it was -7.0, -0.21 a play against +0.07 through Week 9. Bryce Young completed 17 of 30 for 200 yards with no touchdowns and no interceptions, and all three sacks came on third or fourth down. The red zone hurt most: 8 pass plays inside the 20 worth -5.7, with incompletions on third and 2 at the 3 and third and 2 at the 2. Chuba Hubbard was the best receiver on the field, 5 catches on 5 targets for 80 yards.

The run game ran to its average and won where the yards were shortest; success rate, the share of plays that gained what the situation asked for, shows how rarely it worked otherwise: 28.1% of 32 rush plays, for 97 yards and 2 touchdowns, worth +0.009 EPA a play against +0.014 through Week 9. Hubbard carried 27 times for 92 yards and both scores. The 9 runs with 2 yards or fewer to go were worth +5.1, among them a fourth-and-1 conversion at his own 26 in the third, a fourth-and-2 touchdown from the 2 and the third-and-1 score that retook the lead. The work faded: 16 runs before halftime worth +2.8, 16 after it worth -2.5.

The pass defense held New Orleans well under its standard, and EPA per play allowed tells it: 38 pass plays worth -0.13 apiece against +0.05 allowed through Week 9. On defense a negative number is good. Tyler Shough completed 25 of 35 for 187 yards, a touchdown and an interception, and Patrick Jones II, Jaelan Phillips and Derrick Brown each sacked him. The interception came on the Saints' first possession: fourth and 1 at the Carolina 40, Devin Lloyd picked off a short throw for Chris Olave and returned it 41 yards to the New Orleans 23, -6.4 EPA for the Saints and 16.3 points of win probability, the estimate of each side's chance to win. The flags were the cost. On the drive that put New Orleans ahead in the fourth, two neutral-zone infractions, a horse-collar on Phillips that wiped out his own 17-yard sack and a 17-yard pass interference on Corey Thornton on third and 2 at the 19 added 42 yards. Alvin Kamara caught the touchdown two plays later.

The run defense Smashed the Saints, and total EPA allowed sizes it: 23 rush plays worth -15.4, -0.67 a play against +0.007 allowed through Week 9. Here a big negative number is good. Only 17.4% of the runs succeeded, and Travis Etienne, Audric Estime and Kamara carried 17 times for 24 yards. Phillips recovered a Shough fumble at the Carolina 41 early in the second quarter, and that drive ended in Hubbard's first touchdown. The stand that followed kept it 7-0. With 3:56 left in the half, third and 1 at the Carolina 25, Tyrel Dodson and Lloyd stopped Estime for no gain; on fourth and 1 Lee Hunter dropped him for a 1-yard loss, -3.7 EPA. The Saints' six runs with 2 yards or fewer to go gained 2 yards.

The game turned in the last 3:43. Down 14-10 after Kamara's touchdown, Carolina went 68 yards in six plays. Young found Hubbard for 29 on first down, and on second and 6 at the New Orleans 35 Hubbard took a short throw to the right 34 yards to the 1: +3.4 EPA and 24.6 points of win probability. He was stopped twice, then scored over left tackle on third and 1 with 1:51 left. Charlie Smyth's 55-yarder tied it with 45 seconds to go. Then, second and 10 at the Carolina 34 with 28 seconds left, Kool-Aid McKinstry was flagged for pass interference on a throw for Jalen Coker, 30 yards to the New Orleans 36 and 19.5 points of win probability. Hubbard ran for no gain, and Fitzgerald's 54-yarder was worth 29.0 points, the largest swing of the game. His 55-yarder in the third, after a 48-yard miss in the second, was his longest of the season.

Last week's episode asked whether a pass defense that allowed +0.22 a play against the Broncos and drew four pass-interference flags would get back to its standard. It did better: -0.13 a play allowed, against +0.05 through Week 9, and one pass-interference flag. The one to watch next: whether a passing game worth +6.0 on first and second down can stop handing it back on third, after 2 successes on 12 third- and fourth-down pass plays.

That's your Panthers, every game, by the numbers. Muffed does the same deep dive for all 32 teams. Follow the Panthers on Muffed and next week's episode is waiting the moment it's out. No theater. Just the football.

_Data via nflverse._

Every Panthers episode

Season reviews, draft recaps and every game recap, in one place.

More like this