Steelers 18, Bengals 38 — Week 10: 231 Yards to One Receiver
2026 NFL Season · Monday, Nov 16
Pittsburgh lost 38-18 at Cincinnati out of its bye, trailing 24-3 at halftime after Aaron Rodgers went 4 of 12 for 25 yards before the break, while Joe Burrow threw for 409 yards and Ja'Marr Chase caught 11 passes for 231.
The full read
Pittsburgh lost 38-18 at Cincinnati on Sunday, coming out of its bye, and fell to 6-3, a game behind the 7-2 Bengals it beat 30-27 in Week 3. The Steelers trailed 24-3 at halftime and 31-3 after three quarters, and both of their touchdowns came in the fourth. Nine drives produced two touchdowns, a field goal and three three-and-outs; two trips inside the Cincinnati 20 produced 3 points.
The passing game did nothing until the game was gone, and expected points added (EPA), what a play is worth given down, distance and field position against what the situation was already worth, splits it cleanly: 13 first-half pass plays worth -5.7, two of them successful, then 22 after the break worth +2.5. For the game it was -3.2, -0.09 a play against -0.11 through Week 9. Aaron Rodgers completed 15 of 29 for 143 yards and 2 touchdowns, with no interceptions and three sacks; before halftime he was 4 of 12 for 25. DK Metcalf caught 2 of 6 for 54 and Pat Freiermuth 2 of 3 for 35, each with a touchdown, both with Pittsburgh down at least 20.
The run game ran to its average, and success rate, the share of plays that gained what the situation asked for, shows it: 12 of 22 rush plays, 54.5%, for 103 yards, worth +0.11 EPA a play against +0.12 through Week 9. The volume was late. Seven first-half runs were worth -0.01 a play and 15 after it +0.17, six of them Lew Nichols III's for 43 yards on the last drive, with Mason Rudolph at quarterback. Jaylen Warren ran 7 times for 15 yards and -3.7 EPA, after 17 for 127 against Cincinnati in Week 3. Rico Dowdle ran 5 times for 26.
The pass defense was Muffed, and total EPA allowed sizes it: Cincinnati's 43 pass plays were worth +25.5, +0.59 a play against -0.06 allowed through Week 9. On defense a big positive number is bad. Joe Burrow completed 35 of 44 for 409 yards and 4 touchdowns, and 65.1% of Cincinnati's pass plays succeeded. Ja'Marr Chase caught 11 of 14 for 231, the most by any player in a game this season through Sunday. The worst of it came up 10-0 with 7:54 left in the half: first and 10 at the Cincinnati 31, no huddle, Burrow threw deep down the left side and Chase ran to the Pittsburgh 16 for 53 yards, +3.4 EPA, before Asante Samuel Jr. brought him down. Chase Brown caught a 2-yard touchdown three snaps later. Samuel was also flagged for a 26-yard pass interference that set up the first touchdown. Patrick Queen had the only sack.
The run defense held closer to form, and EPA per play allowed is the measure: Cincinnati's 20 rush plays were worth +0.10 apiece against -0.09 allowed through Week 9, 45% of them successful, for 78 yards. Here a negative number is good. Chase Brown ran 10 times for 44. The stop that mattered most did not come: fourth and 1 at the Cincinnati 45 late in the first quarter, Samaje Perine gained exactly the yard, and that drive ended in a touchdown.
The game was put out of reach in the last 1:52 of the half. Down 17-0 at the Cincinnati 18, a throw to Ben Skowronek on second and 8 gained nothing, and on third and 8 Jonathan Allen sacked Rodgers for a 9-yard loss to the 27: 3.3 points of win probability, the estimate of each side's chance to win. Chris Boswell made it from 45 for 17-3. Dohnte Meyers returned the kickoff 39 yards to the Cincinnati 43, and Burrow moved 57 yards in 1:16, Meyers catching a 15-yard touchdown with 14 seconds left. Pittsburgh's chance to win went from 13.4% with two minutes left in the half to 4.9% after that touchdown.
The episode before the bye asked whether a passing game with a 36% success rate, and no completion on four goal-to-go throws against Cleveland, could turn red-zone trips into touchdowns when the run game did not gain 200 yards. Not here: 31.4% of pass plays succeeded, the two trips inside the 20 produced a field goal, and the touchdowns came from 22 and 27 yards out. The one to watch next: whether a passing game worth -5.7 on 13 first-half pass plays here can produce before the score forces it to.
That's your Steelers, every game, by the numbers. Muffed does the same deep dive for all 32 teams. Follow the Steelers on Muffed and next week's episode is waiting the moment it's out. No theater. Just the football.
_Data via nflverse._
Every Steelers episode
Season reviews, draft recaps and every game recap, in one place.