Dolphins 22, Colts 24 — Week 10: Three Kicks Wide Left

2026 NFL Season · Monday, Nov 16

Miami lost 24-22 at Indianapolis after Zane Gonzalez missed field goals from 47 and 51 and an extra point, all wide left, on a day its defense held Daniel Jones to 108 passing yards and Chris Johnson returned an interception 59 yards for a touchdown.

The full read

Miami lost 24-22 at Indianapolis, its third straight loss, and fell to 1-8. Kyle McCord threw 32 of its 33 passes in his first game this season, after Malik Willis had thrown all but one through Week 9. The defense scored a touchdown and held Daniel Jones to 108 passing yards; the kicking cost the game. Zane Gonzalez made a 53-yard field goal and missed from 47 and 51 and on an extra point, all wide left. 12 drives produced two touchdowns, a field goal, a lost fumble, two turnovers on downs and two three-and-outs.

The passing game was below its standard and fell further after halftime, and expected points added (EPA), what a play is worth given down, distance and field position against what the situation was already worth, measures it: 36 pass plays worth -0.26 apiece against -0.10 through Week 9, 14 before the break worth -0.9 in all, 22 after it worth -8.4. McCord completed 17 of 32 for 209 yards with no touchdowns and no interceptions, and was sacked three times. The first sack, on the opening snap of the second half at the Miami 10, was a fumble the Colts recovered in the end zone for a 21-7 lead. The touchdown came from wide receiver Malik Washington, who threw 34 yards to Jalen Tolbert to tie it 7-7. Caleb Douglas caught 3 of 8 for 71, and Kevin Coleman Jr. 1 of 6 for 6, -5.6 EPA on his targets.

The run game rarely gained what it needed, and success rate, the share of plays that gained what the situation asked for, says how rarely: 26.9% of 26 rush plays, for 78 yards and a touchdown, -0.20 EPA a play against -0.02 through Week 9. Ollie Gordon II ran 20 times for 76 yards, with a 19-yarder on second and 6 in the second quarter his longest. Jaylen Wright ran 3 times for -2, and Kaytron Allen once for no gain. McCord's 3-yard run on the first snap of the fourth quarter was the touchdown, 22-24, and his two-point throw for Greg Dulcich fell incomplete.

The pass defense won its half of the game outright, and EPA per play allowed is the measure: the Colts' 23 pass plays were worth -0.64 apiece against +0.26 allowed through Week 9. On defense a big negative number is good. Jones completed 11 of 22 for 108 yards and was intercepted twice, and the Colts' 10 pass plays after halftime were worth -15.0. Michael Taaffe picked off a fourth-and-5 throw at the Miami 37 in the second quarter. Up 21-10 in the third, first and 10 at the Miami 48, Chris Johnson stepped in front of a short throw for Andrew Ogletree at the 41 and ran it back 59 yards for a touchdown: -10.1 EPA for the Colts and 18.2 points of win probability, the estimate of each side's chance to win.

The run defense allowed a little more than usual, and total EPA allowed shows how even it was: the Colts' 32 rush plays were worth -0.3, -0.01 a play against -0.04 allowed through Week 9. Here a negative number is good. The first half was the problem. 19 runs went for +3.7 and 52.6% success, and Seth McGowan's 23-yard run on second and 6 took the ball to the Miami 1 before the Colts' second touchdown. After the break, 13 runs succeeded twice. Up 21-16, third and 2 at the Miami 34, Rodney McGraw and Kenneth Grant held Jonathan Taylor to a yard, and the Colts settled for a 51-yard field goal.

The game turned on the kick that would have led. Down 24-22 with 9:54 left, Miami had driven to the Indianapolis 33 on Douglas's 22-yard catch and a 6-yard Gordon run, and Gonzalez's 51-yard try went wide left: 17.3 points of win probability. His missed extra point after Johnson's touchdown was why the Dolphins had needed two to tie. They got one more chance, from their own 42 with 3:15 left after Washington's 15-yard punt return. Gordon ran for 6, 10 and 1 to the Indianapolis 41, then McCord missed Douglas, CJ Allen sacked him for 8 yards on third and 9, and the fourth-and-17 throw for Coleman fell incomplete, 20.8 points of win probability, the largest swing of the game.

Last week's episode asked whether a pass defense that allowed -0.01 a play against Detroit, against +0.30 through Week 8, could hold anywhere near that level again. It went further: -0.64 a play, with a takeaway on each side of halftime. The one to watch next: whether the passing game can hold up after halftime, after Miami's 22 second-half pass plays here were worth -8.4.

That's your Dolphins, every game, by the numbers. Muffed does the same deep dive for all 32 teams. Follow the Dolphins on Muffed and next week's episode is waiting the moment it's out. No theater. Just the football.

_Data via nflverse._

Every Dolphins episode

Season reviews, draft recaps and every game recap, in one place.

More like this